Overview
With magnetic hall effect gaming keyboards gaining popularity, the market for magnetic hall effect switches have been in demand. Stock switches have become much better over recent years, but for magnetic hall effect switches they are still a work in progress especially for their compatibility in different magnetic hall effect keyboards. Unlike traditional MX switches, not all magnetic hall effect switches are compatible with every magnetic hall effect keyboard or PCB. It is especially important to make sure the hall effect switch is compatible otherwise the difference in the magnetic flux could break the hall effect PCB.
Wooting is one of the names in the magnetic hall effect space that has been on the rise. Here are some switches that are compatible with Wooting hall effect keyboards.
Compatible Switches
As of now there are only a few aftermarket switches compatible with the Wooting HE PCBs, which include:
- Gateron Magnetic Jade switches
- Gateron Magnetic Jade Pro switches
- Wuque WS Dash Magnetic HE switches
- Gateron KS-20 switches
Gateron Magnetic Jade
Product Details
Name | Gateron Magnetic Jade |
Type | Linear |
Top Housing Material | PC |
Bottom Housing Material | Nylon |
Stem Material | POM |
Operation Force | 30±7gf |
Initial Magnetic Flux | 120±15Gs |
Bottom Out Magnetic Flux | 800±80Gs |
Pre Travel | Freely setting |
Total Travel | 3.5±0.2mm |
Lube | Factory lubed |
Lifetime | 100 million keystrokes |
Switch Feel
The Gateron Magnetic Jade feels cleaner to type on relative to any current magnetic switches that come stock with the HE gaming keyboards. They have significantly less stem wobble than other magnetic switches and significantly tighter housings (possibly because their top housing has two more anchors that latch on to the bottom housing in addition to the typical four latches). The Gateron Magnetic Jade also has a more solid feeling bottom out, which might be because their bottom housings are fully enclosed whereas some magnetic switches have open bottoms.
Gateron Magnetic Jade feels comfortable to type on without worrying about unnecessary fatigue, which is perfect for gamers and seasoned enthusiasts.
Switch Sound
Due to its materials, the Gateron Magnetic Jade has a sound profile characterized by a full and poppy mid-range bottom-out sound (possibly due to the nylon bottom housing) and a sharp yet thin top-out sound (possibly due to the harder PC top housing). The bottom-out sound is full and rich in the mid-range. The top-out sound is sharp but less pronounced possibly due to the lighter spring.
Sound test of the Gateron Magnetic Jade:
Gateron Magnetic Jade Pro
Product Details
Name | Gateron Magnetic Jade Pro |
Type | Linear |
Top Housing Material | PC |
Bottom Housing Material | PA66 |
Stem Material | POM |
Operation Force | 36±5g |
Pre Travel | Freely setting |
Total Travel | 3.5±0.1mm |
Lube | Factory lubed |
Lifetime | Over 100 million keystrokes |
The Gateron Magnetic Jade Pro is essentially the same switch as the Gateron Magnetic Jade with an improved arc-shaped light diffuser and a slightly heavier spring weight.
Switch Feel
The Gateron Magnetic Jade Pro similar to the Gateron Magnetic Jade. It is just as smooth and clean to type on with, but now with a relatively snappier return due to the heavier spring. Just like the Gateron Magnetic Jade, the Gateron Magnetic Jade Pro is a well refined magnetic Hall Effect switch that satisfy your typing and gaming needs.
Switch Sound
The Gateron Magnetic Jade Pro sounds similar to the Gateron Magnetic Jade since they are made of the same materials as well. There is a slight difference in the volume of the sound when the switch returns on top out. The Gateron Magnetic Jade Pro has a slightly snappier sound due to the heavier spring creating more force when released. Just like the Gateron Magnetic Jade, the Gateron Magnetic Jade Pro sounds full and poppy without and spring ping or unsettling plastic rattles. The Gateron Magnetic Jade Pro would be another great option for a clean and crisp gaming switch.
Wuque WS Dash Magnetic HE
Product Details
Name | Wuque WS Dash Magnetic HE |
Type | Linear |
Top Housing Material | PC |
Bottom Housing Material | PA |
Stem Material | POM |
Preload | 30±10gf |
Bottom Out Force | 55±10gf |
Pre Travel | Freely setting |
Total Travel | 3.5mm |
Lube | Factory lubed |
Lifetime | 100 million keystrokes |
The Wuque WS Dash HE share similarities with the Gateron Magnetic Jade. They are both manufactured by Gateron and share similar construction materials, including PC top housing, nylon bottom housing, and POM stems. They appear visually identical, with similar mold designs across their components. However, there are notable differences between these two switches:
Stem Color and Spring Weight: The Gateron Magnetic Jade has a white stem with a 50g bottom-out force, while the Wuque WS Dash HE has a purple stem with a 55g bottom-out force.
Switch Feel
Similar to the Gateron Magnetic Jade, the Wuque WS Dash HE feels clean to type on and has tighter tolerances compared to other magnetic HE switches. They are smooth to actuate with a solid bottom out. Compared to the Gateron Magnetic Jade, the Wuque WS Dash He feels slightly heavier to type on with its heavier spring. Like the Gateron Magnetic Jade, the Wuque WS Dash HE is comfortable to type on with little to no fatigue.
Switch Sound
Similar to the Gateron Magnetic Jade, The Wuque WS Dash HE sounds full with a poppy bottom out in the mid-range and a thin and sharp top out in the mid to high range. Compared to the Gateron Magnetic Jade, the Wuque WS Dash HE sounds slightly louder and more distinct due to its heavier spring weight.
Here is a sound test of the Wuque WS Dash HE:
KS-20
Product Details
Name | Gateron KS-20 Dual-Rail Magnetic Orange |
Type | Linear |
Top Housing Material | PC |
Bottom Housing Material | PA66 |
Stem Material | POM |
Operation Force | 30±7gf |
Initial Magnetic Flux | 102±15Gs |
Bottom Out Magnetic Flux | 905±80Gs |
Pre Travel | Freely setting |
Total Travel | 4.1±0.2mm |
Lube | Factory lubed |
Lifetime | 150 million keystrokes |
Switch Feel
The Gateron KS-20 Dual-Rail Magnetic Orange is a full travel switch with a soft bottom out. The soft bottom out could be due to the hollowed-out area in the bottom housing where the stem rails would make contact. This design makes the Gateron KS-20 Dual-Rail Magnetic Orange feel like it travels slightly further at a total travel of 4.1mm. Gateron KS-20 Dual-Rail Magnetic Orange feels smooth with no noticeable scratch or leaf/spring ping. The Gateron KS-20 Dual-Rail Magnetic Orange also has a dual-rail stem design to help reduce stem wobble and increase tolerances, but due to the open bottom housing, the bottom out has some wobble.
Switch Sound
The Gateron KS-20 Dual-Rail Magnetic Orange is slightly lower pitched and on the quieter side. The open bottom housing of the Gateron KS-20 Dual-Rail Magnetic Orange could create a thinner and quieter sound due to the some of the sound dispersing out of the opening. The deeper sound profile of the Gateron KS-20 Dual-Rail Magnetic Orange could be due to the stem making more contact with the bottom housing because of its additional travel distance tolerance. The Gateron KS-20 Dual-Rail Magnetic Orange has a dampened low-pitched profile that would be a good option for a relatively softer typing and gaming experience.
Here is a sound test of the Gateron KS-20 Dual Rail Magnetic Orange:
Additional Notes
Before installing any magnetic hall effect switches on your keyboard, check and ensure they are compatible with your keyboard. Depending on the design of the board, incompatible magnetic switches may damage the HE PCB.
When in doubt if a switch is compatible with the Wooting PCB, it is recommended to reach out to Wooting at their discord.
Other Reading
HMX Violet and JWK WOB | Rainy75 Switch Review
HMX Cheese Linear Switch Review
HMX Macchiato Linear Switch Review
Cherry MX Black Clear Top "Nixie" Linear Switch Review
Durock Silent Switches Review | Dolphin, Shrimp, Daybreak Silent Switches
Top 10 Mechanical Keyboard Switches You Need to Know About in 2024
Top Mechanical Keyboard Layouts: Which One is Right for You?
How to Build Your First Mechanical Keyboards: A Step-by-Step Guide
Share:
HMX x 80Retros Film Switches: KD200, FJ400, Game 1989 Classic | Linear Switch Review
Top List of Hall Effect Switches Compatible with Meletrix Boog75